Select Page


Desert Island Discs is older than one-day cricket, Check Match Particular and coated pitches. It was born on the BBC Forces Programme in 1942, the identical yr as Mike Brearley, one of many 20 or so cricketers to have been stranded on the island with eight information, a e-book and a luxurious, the works of Shakespeare and a Bible. The format was devised by Roy Plomley when the considered being swept away to a desert island would have had nice enchantment in a rustic at warfare, but it surely has endured for nearly 80 years and an invite to look on the programme has change into higher than a spot on the honours listing for some.

The primary cricketing castaways have been Denis Compton and Invoice Edrich in 1951. They have been additionally the primary of the programme’s friends to be shipwrecked collectively, so linked have been they within the public’s creativeness because the Middlesex Twins. Jim Laker was subsequent, only a few weeks earlier than his 19-wicket slice of historical past at Previous Trafford in 1956. Laker’s look is without doubt one of the earliest of which a small audio section survives. He complained that an excessive amount of cricket was being performed, a perpetual chorus of cricketers by way of the ages.

Laker has been adopted by most of the sport’s nice and good: Hutton, Bedser (luxurious – a razor), Fingleton, Constantine, Worrell, Sheppard, Cowdrey, Boycott (a phone line right into a sports activities newspaper), Greig, Randall (a shower with heat water), Brearley, Trueman (a pair of binoculars), Gower (video cassettes of Rumpole of the Bailey), Edmonds (Royal Jamiaca cigars), Botham (fishing rod), Imran Khan (a shotgun and clay pigeon entice), Hen, and Flintoff (a household photograph album).

Cricket has been higher represented than another sport by a distance and commentators function strongly too: Arlott, Alston, Johnston, West (a set of gardening instruments), Blofeld and Agnew (a lawnmower plus gas). Certainly, within the 21st century there have been extra appearances by broadcasters than gamers, if we assume that Jonathan Agnew’s invitation was not in belated recognition of his 4 Check wickets. Maybe this displays cricket’s shrinking profile behind the paywall, or simply the altering style of the presenters and producers. Does the exclusion of different pursuits from cricketers’ lives, as they’re required to focus single-mindedly on the sport from an early age, deprive them of a hinterland and make them much less fascinating individuals?

No lady cricketer has been despatched to the island since Rachael Heyhoe Flint (a ukulele) in 1969. Of cricket’s Crusoes, solely Arlott has appeared twice, in 1953 and 1975. Sadly, neither recording is presently out there. When he was first forged away, Arlott’s luxurious merchandise was a second-hand bookshop. Twenty-two years later his priorities had modified – he requested champagne as a substitute.

John Main was extra bold than Arlott. His island contained a full-scale duplicate of The Oval. Host Sue Lawley was clearly grumpy about this, her tone suggesting that she regarded it because the Desert Island Discs equal of Mankading, however she felt unable to overrule the incumbent prime minister.

Main selected Arlott’s commentary of Bradman’s ultimate Check innings at The Oval in 1948 as one among his information. The author Geoffrey Moorhouse, he of The Finest Liked Sport, did the identical. Charlie Watts of The Rolling Stones additionally picked Arlott, however commentating on Laker in 1956. Henry Blofeld had Arlott on the “freaker” at Lord’s in 1975, spliced with the Johnston/Agnew leg-over commentary from 1991. Agnew additionally selected this, however the prize for probably the most self-regarding collection of cricket commentary goes to Colin Cowdrey, who supposed to spend blissful evenings beneath the celebrities listening to an outline of his century towards South Africa at The Oval in 1960 by Arlott and Richie Benaud (who made his BBC debut on the radio that summer time). One other conceited alternative was by Alec Bedser, who requested the Alec Bedser Calypso by Lord Kitchener and the St Vincent Road Six.

Solely two friends needed the means to look at cricket whereas on the island. Predictably, Dickie Hen was one. Much less so Frank Worrell, who desired a projector with movie of previous matches. If audio of simply one of many misplaced programmes could possibly be rediscovered, it needs to be Worrell’s; he died too quickly to go away a lot spoken report of his life and knowledge.

Wisden is a well-liked alternative of e-book amongst cricket people, but it surely pays to phrase the request correctly. Cowdrey requested for the 1956 version, in order that if he bored with listening to about himself on the radio he may examine his success on his first tour of Australia in 1954–55. Hen requested for the newest version, however Boycott and Bedser each demanded the entire set. Tony Greig stated that he needed sufficient Wisdens to write down a e-book about his profession, so Plomley allowed a variety relationship again to when Greig was an eight-year-old.

Essentially the most cricket-focused collection of all (though Tim Rice’s luxurious was a cricket bag) was by a footballer. Gary Lineker selected Wisden and a bowling machine (he thought that there can be willow bushes on the island so he may knock up a bat himself), and picked the BBC cricket theme Soul Limbo by Booker T and the MGs as his favorite report.

What do the discs say in regards to the cricketers who select them? Usually nothing that we didn’t already know. Geoff Boycott’s favorite disc in 1971 was My Manner. Tony Greig’s selections learn like a playlist from Household Favourites within the late 1960s or early 1970s, although it does cement his transnational popularity for being all issues to all people: Vera Lynn singing There’ll All the time Be an England was adopted by Kenneth McKellar with Scotland the Courageous. This was some years earlier than Greig found his Sri Lankan aunt.

Ian Botham had his mates provide a great proportion of the music – The Rolling Stones, Eric Clapton, Elton John – but additionally picked items by Beethoven, Tchaikovsky and Elgar. The Solar Has Received His Hat On was an apt alternative by Derek Randall, who additionally opted for the staff track of the 1972 Australians, Right here Come the Aussies. To the tune of Chelsea’s “Blue is the Color”, the Aussies trilled such deathless lyrics as: “We’ll play on by way of the English rain.” Randall additionally upheld the custom of selecting a cricketing calypso with The Bumper Music by The Bumpers, which he devoted to Jeff Thomson firstly of the 1977 Ashes.

Nevertheless, Randall was outdone by Fred Trueman, who produced a recording of the Yorkshire staff of the 1960s singing a quantity referred to as Tables and Chairs, basically an property agent’s stock backed by what we’ll loosely name music. Trueman selected Harold Macmillan’s memoirs as his e-book. We all know that Fred was a Conservative supporter, however would he agree with the previous prime minister that within the 1950s the British had “by no means had it so good”? “By no means ’advert it so ’ard extra like. Let ’im bowl 2,000 overs a season and see ’ow good ’e felt. I have no idea…”

Essentially the most intellectual music choice (discounting that of Neville Cardus, there extra as a music critic) was by Learie Constantine in 1963. He selected Massanet, Beethoven and Saint-Saëns in addition to two tracks by Paul Robeson, who, like Constantine, was a campaigner for racial equality, and there was the inevitable calypso.

Imran Khan, who appeared in 1991, might need been reconciling himself to a life in politics together with his selections of I Can See Clearly Now, You Can’t All the time Get What You Need, and It’s All Over Now, Child Blue. Or was he merely paying homage to the extra carefree partying days of his youth?

Maybe the 2 standout performances on Desert Island Discs are by Phil Edmonds and Andrew Flintoff. There are dozens of cricketers with extra distinguished careers than Edmonds who’ve by no means got here near an invite to the island. That he did so was because of the admiration of Michael Parkinson, briefly host of the present after the dying of Plomley. Parkinson launched Edmonds in 1986 by saying that the Middlesex spinner needs to be England captain, an opinion that his visitor made no try to disagree with, although neither did he dissent from his spouse’s description of him as “an insupportable prat”.

Edmonds described how attempting he discovered the “infantile behaviour” of his teammates, and exhibits no sympathy for press intrusion in what he calls their “supposed personal lives”. Such disregard of the staff ethos wouldn’t be tolerated now however it’s a shock he received away with it even again then, contemplating that the programme was broadcast simply as he set off to spend 4 months together with his teammates in Australia. Edmonds additionally makes clear that his alternative of I Simply Referred to as to Say I Love You was not supposed as a rapprochement with Mike Brearley – he stated his fractious relationship together with his captain was like “falling out with a fantasy”.

It grew to become obvious that Edmonds had what many fashionable sports activities stars lack: perspective drawn from life expertise. He described how his household was ostracised from colonial society in Zambia for providing help to Kenneth Kaunda and the independence motion, solely to see those that had shunned them rewarded when Kaunda took energy. It’s our loss that Edmonds has not spared a number of the time commentating that he has spent on making, shedding and re-making his hundreds of thousands since retiring.

Just a few months later, Parkinson had Edmonds’ spouse Frances, who had change into well-known for her warts-and-all tour diaries – on the present, jollily declaring that one of many sights of isolation on the island can be getting away from “Philippe Henri”. However two of her music selections have been the identical as his, and her luxurious Bollinger ’69 would complement his Royal Jamaica cigars completely.

When Kirsty Younger launched Flintoff in 2015 it was as “Freddie”, which was how he had recognized himself to her. Through the interview she coaxed the extra considerate, weak Andrew to come back out of his hiding place in Freddie’s shadow. He spoke, with out self-pity, about his points with alcohol and despair. The music selections have been Andrew’s not Fred’s. There was Judy Garland and Frank Sinatra (“I don’t like this boom-boom music”). He was one among a minority of castaways to decide on a novel (To Kill a Mockingbird), just because he loved it.

Issue 31 of The Nightwatchman is out now.




Challenge 31 of The Nightwatchman is out now.

This was Desert Island Discs at its greatest, permitting the listeners to study extra about an individual and seeing past their public picture. Freddie has had deserved success together with his TV profession since he was forged away, however it will be good to listen to from Andrew sometimes.

This text is from The Nightwatchman. Purchase the brand new situation of the journal for simply £8 + p&p (print version) or £4 (digital version) while you use coupon code GSN31.



Supply hyperlink